WARRIORBRONZE
Historical reconstructions

The Sumerian Warrior

Reconstructing weapons, protection and clothing in Early Dynastic Mesopotamia, c. 2500 BC.

Complete Sumerian soldier reconstruction with helmet, shield, skirt and spotted cloak
IntroductionThe spearThe axeThe shieldThe helmetThe skirtThe spotted cloakEannatum’s club and the origin of the khopeshQueen Puabi’s sickle blade

Introduction

Early Dynastic Sumer introduced several key developments that are essential to civilization, such as writing and cities. Of particular interest to this audience is a new focus on depicting warfare in art—greater detail, new techniques like inlays and the combination of materials, and larger dimensions. Two magnificent examples highlight this shift in the art of war: The Stele of the Vultures and the Standard of Ur.

The first is a carved monumental stone stele created to celebrate the victory of Eannatum of Lagash. The second is a wooden box, with inlaid imagery, found in the Royal Tomb at Ur, likely commemorating another victory in battle. Both pieces are two-sided: the Stele of the Vultures has a "battle" side and a "divine" side, while the Standard of Ur features a "war" side and a "peace" side.

The war/battle sides present a fundamentally new and detailed image of warriors or soldiers—showing their clothing, weaponry, and formations. However, there are still interpretative gaps: What materials were the depicted objects made of? How were they constructed? Was there a specific artistic logic behind how the Sumerian artists captured the 3D world on their canvas? To aid in understanding, archaeological findings, particularly from the Royal Tombs of Ur, provide valuable context.

There have been several attempts to reconstruct the Sumerian soldier in 2D. Probably the best known is Angus McBride’s 1981 illustration of a Sumerian heavy infantryman (from Osprey Military’s Men at Arms series on Ancient Armies of the Middle East). Another, likely familiar to this audience, is the front cover of the 2008 edition of Ancient Warfare magazine.

Below, I present my reconstructions of the Sumerian soldier and aspects of the equipment associated with their leaders.

Select an image to view it at full resolution. Close × or press Escape to return.

The spear

The spear or lance was, alongside the axe, evidently the main weapon of the Sumerian soldier. The tombs contained a great variety of spearhead sizes, and, importantly, clear evidence that some of these were made for hurling. This evidence comes in the shape of bronze spear butts with nocks, used either with a cord or with an atlatl. The wooden shafts were not preserved, so it is not possible to pair specific spearheads to specific spear butts. It is likely that it was the shorter and lighter spearheads that were used as hurling spears with the aid of a cord or an atlatl.

The replicated spearhead is based on one of the larger specimens from the Royal Tombs of Ur, and it is reconstructed with a 2.4 m-long ash shaft to form a heavy thrusting lance. A bronze collar was fitted as a guard against splitting, inspired by the preserved luxury shafts from the Ur burials—these had similar collars made from silver and gold, as well as spearheads made from those metals. The idea was to replicate the kind of lance seen used in a phalanx formation with a two-handed grip, on both the Standard of Ur and the Vulture Stele.

Select an image to view it at full resolution. Close × or press Escape to return.

The axe

The replica of the Sumerian battle axe has been presented before, as I have made several of these already. Compared to the spearhead, the axe is typologically more advanced in both shape and its provisions for secure fastening. The long shaft-hole ensures a snug fit to the relatively short and light haft. The narrow, rounded edge would have been effective at penetrating shields as well as armour or protective clothing.

Although not entirely clear from the imagery, it is possible that each soldier carried a spear, shield, and axe. If so, the axe would likely have been carried on a belt while the spear was held with a two-handed grip. Notably, in the lower register of the Vulture Stele, soldiers are shown marching with spears upright in their right hands and axes in their left hands.

The haft has been modeled on a (partly) preserved example from one of the tombs at Ur. It is made from elm wood and finished with a mixture of pine tar and beeswax.

Select an image to view it at full resolution. Close × or press Escape to return.

The shield

So, we arrive at the shield—and with it, some controversy.

The Sumerian shield was clearly rectangular and relatively large, reaching from the ground up to somewhere high on the belly. On the Vulture Stele, each shield is shown with six bosses arranged in pairs—none of them at the center, where a boss would typically guard the hand. Here, we encounter a distinct Sumerian artistic logic and approach to depth and perspective in imagery.

Davide Nadali argues that the artist applied a “double perspective,” depicting not what would be visible to a spectator, but rather attempting to give a complete view—or explanation—of the scene. Thus, the six bosses, and the six pairs of hands (each pair holding a spear), all represent a row of six soldiers in depth.

This raises further questions: how could a soldier carry a shield while using both hands to hold a spear? Were there dedicated shield-bearers who did not carry spears? And so on...

The Sumerian shield likely had a single central boss, probably positioned at the center. Apart from the shield boss, there are no other visible details on the shield in the otherwise detailed representation on the Vulture Stele: no rim markings, no indication of individual planks, no patterns suggesting a woven structure. The most plausible explanation is that the shield was covered in hide or leather.

Could a thick bovine rawhide function without any backing? I doubt it. I believe there was a wooden backing, likely made from planks. I made the shield from 6 mm pine and covered it with two goat rawhides. The size I chose—120 cm x 55 cm—made it difficult to find a single hide large enough to cover the entire shield. To avoid stitching the hide around the edge, I first made a seam along the rim of the wooden frame, and then stitched the hide to this seam from the back.

Three cross-beams were sewn to the back of the shield, with the middle one functioning as a handle. These beams, as well as the entire shield, were given a slight curve. A shield with a convex front might seem more advanced than a flat one, but when using rawhide, the shield must be locked into shape during drying anyway, to prevent the rawhide from pulling it into a concave form.

The shield boss was made separately, much like a Viking-period boss, but from thick bovine rawhide. I mounted it with the collar on the back side, stitching it through the shield and the handle. Several artistic reconstructions have pictured the shield bosses as being made of metal. These bosses would have to be quite large, and to match a rawhide boss in performance, I would estimate the metal would need to be over 1 mm thick—probably more—or made of bronze rather than copper.

No such bosses were found in the Royal Tombs of Ur. One object, described as a "metal rosette," possibly from a shield, bears no resemblance to a shield boss. Therefore, I would argue that:

- there is no archaeological evidence of metal bosses.

- they would have been more expensive,

- they would be more difficult to manufacture, especially in an alloy harder than copper, silver or gold (like bronze),

- they would be less functional than a thick rawhide boss.

Anyway – here is one interpretation of the shield used by the soldiers of Lagash!

Selected references:

Nadali, D. 2014: How Many Soldiers on the “Stele of the Vultures”? A Hypothetical Reconstruction. Iraq Vol 76 (141-148).

Woolley, L. 1934: Ur Excavations. Vol. 2. The Royal Cemetery. (London: Publications of the Joint Expedition of the British Museum and of the Museum of the University of Pennsylvania to Mesopotamia, 1934).

Select an image to view it at full resolution. Close × or press Escape to return.

The helmet

All in all we have quite a number of depictions of helmets from Sumer. The helmets are depicted quite similarly—on the Vulture Stele, the Standard of Ur, and other inlay imagery. One difference is that there are no straps for closure on the Vulture Stele. All the helmets seem to have a contour line, about 15–20 mm in from the edge.

Many have proposed the use of copper helmets, and this is certainly a plausible interpretation. Remains of helmets were actually found at Ur, the most famous one from tomb PG 755, which likely belonged to King Meskalamdug. He was buried with a gold helmet strikingly similar to the one worn by King Eannatum on the Vulture Stele. The gold helmet even features a gold hair-bun and earpieces incorporated into the design.

In the dromos at Ur (the passage leading to the tomb area), a group of six soldiers were found. These soldiers carried copper helmets and heavy spears, with bull motifs engraved on the spearheads. This suggests they were an elite guard, possibly the royal guard. The remains were crushed flat, and the shapes of the helmets were distorted. The question arises: were these the same type of helmets as those worn by the common soldiers depicted on the Vulture Stele and the Standard of Ur, or were they of a class between the king’s gold helmet and the regular soldier’s helmet?

Looking at Leonard Woolley’s reconstructive sketches, I notice they differ somewhat from the typical shape in Sumerian imagery: the main difference being that the helmets do not extend down the neck in the rear, and they have distinct "flaps" or "ears" between the front and back. One of them had a chin strap made from silver. From a manufacturing perspective, it would be relatively easy to reproduce the simple bowl shape of the found copper helmets. However, reproducing the more intricate shapes seen in the images would be far more challenging.

This leaves us with two possibilities:

These copper helmets represent the type of helmets used by Sumerian soldiers. It seems unlikely that the common soldiers had more elaborately made helmets than the elite guard with the bull-motif spears. The Sumerian artist may have used a convention in depicting the helmets, opting not to represent them realistically. If the copper helmets had separate organic neck protection, the artist may have chosen not to distinguish this detail.

The main body of soldiers used helmets made of leather or rawhide, closely resembling the ones shown in the imagery.

I chose the second option and made the helmet from medium-thickness bovine rawhide. To closely mimic the shape seen in the images and for ease of manufacture, I introduced a split and seam running vertically down the back from the pointed top. This feature is not visible from the side. The result is a very light, bone-hard helmet that, with interior padding, I believe would be quite effective as protective headgear.

Select an image to view it at full resolution. Close × or press Escape to return.

The skirt

The Sumerian soldier is typically depicted wearing a knee-length skirt with a ragged hemline. Sometimes, the main body of the skirt also features ragged details similar to the hem. Several interpretations have been proposed. The skirts on the Vulture Stele bear a resemblance to the scale armor used later in the Bronze Age. If not made of metal scales, they could have been constructed from similar scales of rawhide or leather. If this is the case, it would suggest that the garment was a military uniform, likely heavy and cumbersome to wear.

However, the main issue with this hypothesis is that similar garments appear to have been worn by both men and women in non-military contexts. Currently, there seems to be a consensus that these garments were likely wrap-around pieces made from a coarse base net or textile, to which tufts of long, unspun sheep fibres were attached. The Greeks later referred to this garment as a "kaunakes," and it was associated with Mesopotamia and Persia.

In this recreation, tufts of long-haired sheep wool (Old Norwegian spæl) are attached to a coarse, plain-woven plant-fibre net, arranged in partly overlapping rows similar to the pattern found on scale armor. This pattern is often clearly depicted in Sumerian imagery, such as on the skirts in the lower register of the Vulture Stele.

As Sumerian texts clearly show, wool played a central role in every aspect of Sumerian society: from the day-to-day management of vast flocks, to grazing and wool collection, to the many labor-intensive steps involved in transforming fibre into thread, woven cloth, and finished garments. Wool was also used as a form of currency, exchanged for copper and tin. It functioned as payment in various social transactions, including marriage arrangements, services, and penalties. It is therefore no surprise that soldiers’ lives were also closely connected to wool through the standard kaunakes skirt.

It might seem odd that one would come up with such a garment in the warm climate of Bronze Age Mesopotamia. It is worth considering the development of textile production at this point: except for a very old use of diverse plant fibres for nets, ropes and probably also some garments, leather had probably been the main material for clothing. Linen textiles predate wool textiles, but its production was labour-intensive and it remained less common than wool. In the millennium before our time at 2500 BC, the use of wool from domesticated sheep had revolutionized clothing, appearance, trade, and the workday of especially women in Mesopotamia. The spinning of thread from wool for making woven textiles was an immense time consuming task, often underestimated. Garments made from woven wool thread would necessarily have been rather expensive. Linen textiles made from the flax plant were known but was still a rare material used for luxury garments. Using tufts of wool, plucked from sheep and cleaned, directly in a garment was a clever and efficient alternative to conventional weaving.

Select an image to view it at full resolution. Close × or press Escape to return.

The spotted cloak

The scenes on the famous Standard of Ur were created as an inlay mosaic of pieces of blue lapis lazuli, red limestone, and pale light-brown shell, all set in a fixture of black bitumen. Possibly, the bitumen was also used to create details on top of the shell pieces—such as contours, eyes, ankle bones, etc.

On the war side of the Standard, soldiers are depicted wearing cloaks with black spots. Once again, we encounter a controversy. Some scholars have argued for a more heavily armoured Sumerian soldier, suggesting that these cloaks were made from leather, reinforced with copper discs. I find this a less likely interpretation. All soldiers appear to wear such cloaks, which would imply the existence of a vast number of copper discs—yet none have been found. A long cloak fitted with, say, fifty or more such discs would also be prone to snagging on vegetation, cords, or gear. While it would be technically possible to fasten each disc tightly enough to avoid this, it seems impractical and inefficient.

Others have suggested that the cloaks were made from the hide of a spotted animal. One might also imagine that such a spotted pattern could have been imitated using sheep wool in different natural colours.

There are two immediate candidates for the original material: the Asiatic cheetah and the Persian leopard, both of which were likely distributed across much of the Near East in prehistory. Both animals have spots evenly distributed across their hides—except for the belly. The leopard's markings resemble more of a rosette than a simple spot.

Other garments from the period, likely made from wool, are often characterized by the highlighting of long wool fibres. If the cloaks were a variant of the later Viking-period vararfeldur—unspun sheep wool attached to a woven background during weaving—I would have expected the Sumerian artist to depict the shaggy texture of the wool. One possible explanation is that a different technique was used, one that bound the locks more tightly into the textile, resulting in a non-shaggy appearance. Still, I believe the cheetah or leopard hide remains the more plausible alternative. It brings with it the symbolism of the predator, a theme not uncommon in warrior iconography throughout history. The Zulu warriors’ use of leopard hide is one such example.

For my reconstruction, I have used high-quality faux cheetah fur for the Sumerian soldier’s cloak. It is slightly tailored at the neck, with a leather strap added for closure. With the spotted cloak, this reconstruction of the Sumerian soldier is complete.

Select an image to view it at full resolution. Close × or press Escape to return.

Eannatum’s club and the origin of the khopesh

Stele of the Vultures: The ruler of Lagash, Eannatum, is depicted leading his soldiers—first on foot (top), then on a wheeled cart (bottom). In the cart scene, he carries a curved object in his right hand, which resembles the weapon later known as a khopesh. What exactly was this object, and what was it made from? This depiction is 700 years older than the Byblos metal khopeshes with their gold and silver inlays. One might suspect that it is simply the reins for a team of donkeys or asses, but reins are generally depicted with two “ribs”, whereas this object has three.

A related object appears on a circular stone base from The House of Fruits in Tello (Girsu), where either a god or a king holds a similar curved object. The shape is even closer to the khopesh, but it lacks any indication of decorations or inlays that characterize the Byblos examples. Archaeologist Herman Müller-Karpe believed both of these objects were made of wood and linked them to Sumerian texts that mention "Krummholz" or "curved wood," as well as the Sumerian-Akkadian term Gamlu(m). These texts describe such objects as being crafted from "Kiskanu" or "êru" wood, often with silver decorations.

In Müller-Karpe’s view, such a curved wooden object, sometimes adorned with silver or gold, was an insignia of power held by kings and gods. Over time, this object evolved into the bronze khopesh, sometimes featuring intricate gold and silver inlays, as seen at Byblos. Could the cobra decoration on the Byblos khopeshes suggest that the curved shape was linked to snake symbolism, even during Eannatum's time, 700 years earlier?

The Vulture Stele club has been reconstructed from elm wood, with imitation-gold inlays and silver-plated bands. The object from the House of Fruits scene has been reconstructed in birch.

Selected references:

Müller, H. W. 1987. Der Waffenfund von Balata-Sichem und Die Sichelschwerter. München, Bayerische Akademie der Wissenschaften.

Select an image to view it at full resolution. Close × or press Escape to return.

Queen Puabi’s sickle blade

The Royal Tombs of Ur contained a great variety of objects, many of which fall outside general typological categories. One such item is the large copper-alloy sickle blade with a gold band, discovered in the tomb of Queen Puabi (also known as Shub-ad). But what kind of object is this, and what was it used for?

The blade is notably large, measuring 30 cm across, with a prominent central rib, giving it a heavy and robust form. I have double-checked the dimensions given by Leonard Woolley against recent scaled images—Woolley was correct: the blade is large.

This blade has often been interpreted as an early stage in the evolutionary development of sickle- and crescent-shaped axes in the ancient Near East—an idea supported by scholars such as Rachel Maxwell-Hyslop and Herman Müller-Karpe. Its considerable size and weight certainly evoke associations with axes or weapons. However, two key factors suggest a different interpretation.

Firstly, the blade was found in an exceptional context: the tomb of Queen Puabi, the same tomb that contained the four lyres and the famed headdress or "crown." While its female elite context does not preclude a martial function, it does open the door to other, more symbolic interpretations.

Secondly, a shell inlay scene from Kish depicts a very similar object mounted on a curved haft, held by a female figure who is shown cutting fish. This is particularly intriguing when considered alongside the legendary figure of Queen Kubaba of Kish, mentioned in the Sumerian King List. Though generally regarded as mythical, Kubaba’s rise to power is said to have begun with a ritual offering of fish to the god Marduk.

Fish held significant ceremonial importance in Sumerian ritual practice. Given this context, we might better interpret the Ur sickle blade as a ritual tool—a functional implement used in religious ceremonies. Its exaggerated size may have served a visual rather than practical purpose, enhancing its symbolic power.

We can envision Queen Puabi wielding this ceremonial sickle during public rituals—perhaps reenacting Kubaba's legendary offering—cutting and serving fish to the gods. A simple flint flake could have done the job, but the use of this gold-embellished “fillet knife,” combined with the grandeur of her regalia, would have turned the act into a powerful spectacle, reinforcing her authority and divine association.

Selected references:

Maxwell-Hyslop, R. 1949: Western Asiatic Shaft-Hole Axes. Iraq. Vol. 11, No. 1 (90-129).

Mackay, E. J. H. 1925: Report on the excavation of the “A” cemetery at Kish, Mesopotamia. Field Museum of Natural History Anthropology Memoirs 1.

Müller, H. W. 1987. Der Waffenfund von Balata-Sichem und Die Sichelschwerter. München, Bayerische Akademie der Wissenschaften.

Tsouparopoulou, C. 2024: The Early Dynastic “Maison des Fruits” at Tell K in Tello (Ĝirsu). Bulletin of ASOR, volume 391.

The Tomb of Queen Puabi is an unlooted, spectacular burial chamber from the 3rd millennium BCE, discovered by Sir Leonard Woolley in the Royal Cemetery at Ur in Mesopotamia. It contained a wealth of well-preserved grave goods, including a magnificent golden headdress, jewelry of gold, silver, carnelian, and lapis lazuli, and evidence of servants and attendants buried with her. A cylinder seal found in the tomb identifies her as "queen" and provides a rare example of an elite woman ruling in her own right.

Mackay, E. J. H. 1925: Report on the excavation of the “A” cemetery at Kish, Mesopotamia. Field Museum of Natural History Anthropology Memoirs 1.

Select an image to view it at full resolution. Close × or press Escape to return.

Available reconstructions

The research project includes experimental and interpretative reconstructions that are not offered for sale. The following weapons and equipment can be ordered from Warriorbronze.

Reconstructed battle axe and spear, Sumerian project

Ur Battle Axe

Bronze axe reconstruction associated with the Royal Cemetery at Ur.

View the Ur axe
Ur spearhead reconstruction

Ur Spearhead

Bronze spearhead reconstructed in connection with the Sumerian warrior project.

View the Ur spearhead
Ur shield reconstruction, rawhide front and wooden back

Ur Shield

Experimental reconstruction of a rectangular rawhide shield with wooden backing.

View the Ur shield

Weapons and equipment by Warriorbronze

Individual reconstructions and commissions can be discussed directly.